A Long Game Project game
17

Game Mechanics Reference

When to Roll a Die

When a player asks to perform an action, follow this 6-step process. It is the same process as the Step-by-Step in Dice & Probability, written for the GM.

  1. Does this require a die roll? If they are never or always going to succeed, don’t bother rolling. Just keep the game going. If the odds are somewhere between 1% and 99% chance of success, this is when to roll.
  2. What stat or skill is being tested? Consider which stat fits the check, and which skill under it. If you are not using skills, pick the stat and move on.
  3. How hard is success? Set the Dice Check (DC) using the probability table below or the DC Difficulty Guide.
  4. Roll the dice. Get the player to roll the 20-sided die. A natural 20 or a natural 1 is a critical result.
  5. Add modifiers. Add or subtract any modifiers to their raw dice roll. This includes stats and abilities.
  6. Describe what happens. Narrate the outcome in fiction.

Skills Reference

Each check tests one of the six core stats. Each stat covers a set of skills. The full descriptions are in Core Skills.

  • Strength (STR): Change Management, Project Delivery, Forceful Operations.
  • Dexterity (DEX): Adaptability, Multitasking, Risk Mitigation.
  • Constitution (CON): Endurance, Crisis Management, Workload Endurance, Stress Tolerance, Adversity Handling, Long-Term Focus.
  • Intelligence (INT): Research, Strategic Thinking, Technical Understanding, Problem Solving, Data Analysis.
  • Wisdom (WIS): Insight, Risk Assessment, Stakeholder Perception, Trend Forecasting, Ethical Judgement.
  • Charisma (CHA): Influence, Negotiation, Leadership, Stakeholder Engagement, Deception.

Dice Check / Probability Table

Probabilistic thinking is a core aim of InsightRPG. Estimating a probability before rolling helps players calibrate their judgement and check their own biases. Committing to a number surfaces hidden assumptions before the dice decide.

Ask the player: "I'd like you to weigh in as an expert here. What do you think your probability of success is from 0-100, and why?" Convert the estimate to a DC using the table below. It is the same table as the Full Probability Table in Dice & Probability.

DC values mapped to probability estimates and percentage chance of success
DC Probability Estimate Probability of Success
1Almost certain95%
2Highly likely95%
3Very likely90%
4Expected85%
5Good chance80%
6Probable75%
7Likely70%
8Quite possible65%
9More often than not60%
10Maybe55%
11Even odds50%
12Perhaps45%
13Somewhat unlikely40%
14Unlikely35%
15Not often30%
16Probably not25%
17Rarely20%
18Remote15%
19Highly unlikely10%
20Extremely unlikely5%

The table stops at DC 20 because a D20 cannot roll higher. The DC Difficulty Guide also has DC 25 (Very unlikely) and DC 30 (Near impossible), which only modifiers can reach.

Roll the Dice / Add Modifiers / Describe What Happens

This example runs steps 2 to 6: pick the stat, set the DC, roll, add the modifier, then describe the outcome.

Go deeper
Train your team
We teach your people to run exercises for your own teams or your clients.
See training →
Question cards
PRISM
552 question cards in 11 decks, for scenario design and debrief.
Explore PRISM →
Need help?
Test a crisis plan
Want an exercise designed and run for you?
Learn more →